The principle of clinical equipoise can be defined as the state or condition at the start of a trial where clinical equipoise regarding the merits of the particular regimens to be tested exists and the trial is designed in manner to make it reasonable to expect that, if the trial is successfully conducted, clinical equipoise will be disturbed. According to this concept of clinical equipoise, the requirement is satisfied if there is genuine uncertainty within the expert medical community. Is the concept of clinical equipoise still relevant to. Equipoise in clinical trials circulation research dois. The use of equipoise in clinical trials sciencedirect. Equipoise andequipoise and proton beam therapyproton. Equipoise, consent and the ethics of randomised clinical. Clinical equipoise, also known as the principle of equipoise, provides the ethical basis for medical research that involves assigning patients to different treatment arms of a.
Although ce has traditionally been indicated as a necessary condition for a morally justified introduction of a new rct, questions related to the interpretation of this principle remain woefully open. Clinical equipoise versus scientific rigor in cancer. Stated briefly, for purposes of clinical trials, clinical equipoise demands that at the time a clinical trial is being carried out there be a state of genuine scientific uncertainty in the medical community over which of the drugs or treatments being tested is more efficacious and safer. Pdf on oct 1, 2000, charles weijer and others published for and against. A predominant ethical view holds that physicianinvestigators should conduct their research with therapeutic intent. Cardiology has been a leading field in generating evidence through large randomized clinical trials rcts. This ohcm 10th edition pdf free download has been hosted at microsoft onedrive and mediafire so that you can instantly access the download without any possible hindrance. Clinical equipoise and riskbenefit assessment franklin g miller. Download clinical methods in medicine clinical skills and practices pdf free. Clinical equipoise was first proposed as a solution to the problem of randomisation 30 years ago. Underlying clinical equipoise is the norm that no patient should be randomized to treatment known or believed by the expert clinical community to be inferior to the established standard of care. The term was first used by benjamin freedman in 1987. Clinical and personal equipoise exists when a clinician has no good basis for a choice between two or more care options or when one is truly uncertain about the.
Jun 25, 2017 clinical equipoise, also known as the principle of equipoise, provides the ethical basis for medical research that involves assigning patients to different treatment arms of a clinical trial. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Clinical equipoise definition of clinical equipoise by. We define it, ask whose equipoise is important and why, and consider the implications of the requirement that equipoise should apply in clinical trials.
Abstract the ethics of clinical research requires equipoise a state of genuine uncertainty on the part of the clinical. Equipoise and the dilemma of randomized clinical trials. Jun 01, 2004 it is widely maintained that a clinical trial is ethical only if some form of equipoise between the treatments being compared obtains. A fifth issue that is levied against the equipoise standard is the fact that maintaining equipoise promotes premature termination of randomized, clinical trials 4. Learning health systems, clinical equipoise and the ethics of. In particular, when extremely positive results are seen and a boundary is crossed, the data monitoring committee for a randomized study may recommend stopping the trial and. Benjamin freedmans concept of clinical equipoise, introduced 30 years ago, famously captured the link between uncertainty and ethics. The influence of clinical equipoise and patient preferences. It is defined as a state of disagreement or uncertainty in the informed, expert medical community about the relative clinical merits of the intervention arms in a trial. Definition of clinical equipoise in the dictionary. Another criticism is that equipoise is unlikely ever to exist, or to persist for long. Clinical equipoise defines the ethical standard for including a patient in a clinical trial. Abstract the ethics of clinical research requires equipoise a state of genuine uncertainty on the part of the clinical investigator regarding the comparative therapeutic merits of each arm in.
Pdf on jan 1, 1990, sophie botros and others published equipoise, consent and the ethics of randomised clinical trials find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. The limits and hazards of clinical equipoise on cardiology. Equipoise andequipoise and proton beam therapyproton beam therapy w robert lee md ms medw. Oct 01, 2010 clinical equipoise defines the ethical standard for including a patient in a clinical trial. Miller and brodys central thesis is that the concept of clinical equipoise conflates the ethics of clinical practice with the ethics of. Equipose definition of equipose by medical dictionary. Its the best clinical book for clinical practice after harrison and arup kundu for medicine posting, used both by fourth year students and interns in clinical wards. A seminal paper by miller and brody 1 clearly laid the general framework on why we should abandon the term clinical equipoise in research. At what level of collective equipoise does a randomized. It is commonly believed in research ethics that some form of equipoise is a necessary condition for justifying randomized clinical trials, that without it clinicians are violating the moral duty to do what is best for the patient. The ethics of clinical research belmont report respect for personsrespect for persons beneficence. To be in equipoise between two treatments, a and b, is to be cognitively indifferent between the statement a is strictly more effective than b and its negation. Clinical equipoise definition of clinical equipoise by the.
Clinical equipoise and riskbenefit assessment franklin g. Payments or rewards that undermine a persons capacity to exercise free. For most manual therapy trials, equipoise does not likely exist. Clinical equipoise is widely regarded as an ethical requirement for the design. A partial defense of clinical equipoise scott d gelfand, 2019. The doctrine of clinical equipoise is appealing because it appears to permit physicians. Enhancing regulatory oversight for challenging clinical trials. Equality in distribution, as of weight, relationship, or emotional forces.
A seminal paper by miller and brody 1 clearly laid the general framework on why we should abandon the term clinical equipoise in. Download clinical methods in medicine clinical skills and. Subject equipoise not requiredsubject equipoise not required informed free unexploited consentinformed, free. Clinical trials, devices, unproven treatments, and clinical.
Clinical equipoise an overview sciencedirect topics. The ethics of clinical research flashcards quizlet. Equipoise, knowledge and ethics in clinical research and. Clinical equipoise and the incoherence of research ethics. A partial defense of clinical equipoise scott d gelfand. Therapeutic misconception in the ethics of clinical tri. Having developed the topic from a purely philosophical perspective, we ask how the concept may be construed mentally. Experience sufficient to prove the safety pipekuroniya clinical equipoise for pregnant women and fetus, there is no. Irrelevance of equipoise the journal of medicine and. A statistical framework for quantifying clinical equipoise. In this part of the article, you will be able to access the.
In the case of general anesthesia for cesarean section pipekuroniya clinical equipoise does not change the index of apgar, muscle tone and cardiovascular adaptation neonatal. In essence, it demands that true ambivalence toward the efficacy of a novel therapy exists among researchers. How should we understand clinical equipoise when doing rcts. The standard of clinical equipoise is met if there is genuine uncertainty within the expert medical community not necessarily on the part of the individual investigator about the preferred treatment. A state of genuine uncertainty as to the advantages or disadvantages of each therapeutic arm in a clinical trial.
In this part of the article, you will be able to download oxford handbook of clinical medicine 10th edition in a. And since a physician offering a therapy wouldnt prescribe secondrate treatments, the experimental intervention and the best proven therapy should appear equally effective. Article information, pdf download for clinical equipoise and. Clinical equipoise, also known as the principle of equipoise, provides the ethical basis for medical research that involves assigning patients to different treatment arms of a clinical trial.
Clinical equipoise, also known as the principle of equipoise, is the ethical principle that in medical research involving randomly assigning patients to different treatment arms, the clinician should have no reason to prefer any one arm over the other. The influence of clinical equipoise and patient preferences on outcomes of conservative manual interventions for spinal pain. Get a printable copy pdf file of the complete article 1. Miller and howard brody, a critique of clinical equipoise. Clinical equipoise is widely regarded as an ethical requirement for the design and conduct of randomized controlled trials rcts. Clinical equipoise and riskbenefit assessment franklin.
Dec, 2011 we argue that a clinician should offer patients the option of recruitment into a trial, even if the clinician is not individually in a position of equipoise, if there is collective clinical equipoise amongst the wider clinical community about the effectiveness of a proposed intervention the clinical equipoise principle. If such clinical equipoise does not exist, then recruitment will be biased and potentially delayed. Investigators participating in such trials must also have clinical equipoise that the treatment under study may or may not be better than the standard treatments available. It serves as a minimum requirement to justify the investigation of a hypothesis, because any therapy believed by. Within this formulation, neither theoretical nor clinical equipoise is deemed a necessary ethical requisite. However, reluctance on the part of the enrolling physician may remain problematic in this approach. It is widely maintained that a clinical trial is ethical only if some form of equipoise between the treatments being compared obtains. Clinical equipoise ce has been proposed as an ethical principle relating uncertainty and moral leeway in clinical research. A different line of criticism of the clinical equipoise requirement begins with the claim that the role of physician and the role of researcher are different, and not recognizing this difference leads theorists to incorrectly conclude that clinical equipoise must be present in order to conduct ethical rcts. Equipoise and the ethics of clinical research nejm. My problem with these posts is that they seem to be understanding clinical equipoise in terms of needing uncertainty about whether or not some intervention makes people better off, without taking into account the costs of doing so relative to how much better off the intervention makes people. Clinical and personal equipoise exists when a clinician has no good basis for a choice between two or more care options or when one is truly uncertain about the overall benefit or harm offered by the treatment to hisher patient. Social value, clinical equipoise, and research in a public. Application of bayesian statistics to decision making during a clinical trial.
Clinical equipoise is defined as the genuine uncertainty within the scientific and. This paper argues that the national institute for health and clinical excellence should not offer guidance in situations where there is insufficient evidence equipoise about the potential benefit of the treatment in question. Recent proposals to rehabilitate ce have divided the bioethical. We have provided the links to hutchinson clinical medicine ebook in pdf format for free download below. Information and translations of clinical equipoise in the most comprehensive dictionary definitions resource on the web. This paper concentrates on the last of these the issue of equipoise. Observations from fda robert skip nelson, md phd deputy director and senior pediatric ethicist. How should we understand clinical equipoise when doing.
Clinical and personal equipoise exists when a clinician has no good basis for a choice between two or more care options or when one is truly uncertain about the overall benefit or harm offered by. At what level of collective equipoise does a clinical trial become ethical. Keywords cioms guidelines, ebola, equipoise, public health emergencies, research ethics, right to try. Clinical equipoise is an important concept concerning the state of knowledge about a particular research topic 67. Oxford handbook of clinical medicine 10th edition pdf free. We have uploaded clinical methods in medicine clinical skills and practices pdf. Dec 28, 2017 clinical equipoise was first proposed as a solution to the problem of randomisation 30 years ago.
Uncertainty about equipoise is more than a scholarly debate. Pdf on jan 1, 1990, sophie botros and others published equipoise, consent and the ethics of randomised clinical trials find, read. Hutchinson clinical medicine manual ebook download free in. Pdf equipoise, or the criterion of honest professional uncertainty in the clinical community, is currently the most widely accepted. In the case of general anesthesia for cesarean section pipekuroniya clinical equipoise does not change the index of apgar, muscle. Equipoise, consent and the ethics of randomised clinical trials. In short, clinical equipoise means that there is genuine uncertainty in the expert medical community. First, without knowing if the treatment is effective no costeffectiveness judgement can be logically made. This page was last edited on 11 september 2019, at 09. Equipoise, knowledge and ethics in clinical research and practice. Clinical trials, devices, unproven treatments, and.
The principle of clinical equipoise is widely endorsed as a foundational ethical requirement governing design and conduct of rcts. We argue that a clinician should offer patients the option of recruitment into a trial, even if the clinician is not individually in a position of equipoise, if there is collective clinical equipoise amongst the wider clinical community about the effectiveness of a proposed intervention the clinical equipoise principle. The requirement that clinicianinvestigators need to have equipoise before randomizing patients to clinical trials is widely accepted in the. Clinical equipoise versus scientific rigor in cancer clinical. Enhancing regulatory oversight for challenging clinical.
197 618 160 513 89 640 87 1098 854 986 140 1265 517 1180 1333 1198 649 1056 1226 284 242 1086 1055 1010 716 1408 1062 1093 320 1400 31 414 597 287